As CFOs contend with AI adoption, transformation, cost pressure and changing board expectations, the strength of the finance leadership team around them matters. We look at four capabilities CFOs should consider when hiring, developing their teams and planning for succession.
CFOs don’t need another article telling them their role has become more strategic. That shift happened some time ago, and CFOs are well aware.
Our conversations with CFOs have moved on too. We talk about AI, changing board expectations, investment decisions, transformation and growth, and increasingly, how to achieve more with less.
All of which puts greater pressure on the senior finance team. CFOs need people around them who can take real ownership of these challenges.
A recent Gartner C-level Communities article asked seven CFOs about the toughest challenges they are facing. Their answers ranged from managing rapid growth and balancing long-term investment with short-term financial discipline, to delivering transformation across people, processes and technology.
Separate Gartner research, surveying more than 200 CFOs, found that 56% ranked enterprise-wide cost optimisation among their top five priorities, while 51% prioritised improving forecast accuracy and quality. Yet confidence around AI and digital talent was considerably lower, with only 36% confident in their ability to drive enterprise AI impact.
These aren’t challenges a CFO can, or should, solve alone. They need senior finance leaders who can operate across traditional functional boundaries, make difficult trade-offs and take ownership of complex business problems.
For CFOs building their teams and thinking about succession, that means looking beyond whether someone has performed a particular role before, and considering the experiences they’ve had, the problems they’ve solved and the decisions they’ve been accountable for.
What capabilities do CFOs need in a high-performing finance leadership team?
Looking at the challenges CFOs are facing today, four capabilities stand out: commercial judgement to make difficult trade-offs, rigorous prioritisation, the ability to connect people, process and technology, and experience of scaling organisations without simply adding cost or complexity.
01
Commercial judgement: can your finance leaders make difficult investment trade-offs?
In the Gartner article, several CFOs point to the tension between investing for the long term and maintaining financial discipline today. That requires finance leaders who are comfortable making decisions when there isn’t a perfect answer.
That means understanding opportunity cost, knowing where to prioritise capital and being prepared to challenge investment assumptions. It also means weighing growth, return, risk and timing, rather than assessing an investment on the numbers alone.
When hiring, it’s worth getting into the decisions someone has actually made:
- What have they chosen not to fund?
- When have they challenged the business on an investment?
- How have they approached a decision when the numbers didn’t provide an obvious answer?
These examples can tell you far more about someone’s commercial judgement than asking them to describe their commercial acumen.
02
Prioritisation: can finance leaders balance transformation with business-as-usual?
Chris Holt at Linklaters describes the simultaneous pressure of organisational change, process improvement, technology, AI and business as usual. His response is to “prioritise ruthlessly.”
That becomes particularly important when multiple transformation programmes are competing for the same people, investment and attention. Finance leaders need to be able to sequence change: what needs to happen now, what can wait and, importantly, what doesn’t need to happen at all.
When assessing candidates, look at how they have managed competing priorities in practice:
- Can they distinguish between what’s important and what’s urgent?
- Have they stopped or delayed initiatives when circumstances changed?
- Can they lead change without losing sight of the day-to-day performance of the function?
03
Technology and AI: can your finance leaders turn investment into business value?
Another challenge highlighted by CFOs is making better use of financial information, improving efficiency and assessing the return on technology investment.
This doesn’t mean every senior finance hire needs to be an AI or technology expert. They do need to understand where technology can improve performance, what needs to change around it and whether the investment is likely to deliver genuine value.
As I explored in my article, What Should Boards Look for When Hiring a CFO in an AI-Driven World?, technology may provide better information, but finance leaders still need to decide what to do with it.
Look for evidence that they can work effectively across finance, technology and operations:
- Can they ask the right questions without needing to be the technical expert?
- Can they challenge the assumptions behind an investment?
- Have they demonstrated that they can turn new technology into better business outcomes?
04
What does the business need technology to change or improve over the next three to five years?
The CFOs talking about growth also highlight the challenge of maintaining culture, governance and financial discipline as an organisation becomes materially larger.
When hiring for that challenge, simply finding someone who has worked in a large organisation doesn’t tell you enough. Someone who has inherited a £5bn finance function hasn’t necessarily learned how to take a £1bn business to £5bn. The experience gained through building, integrating, simplifying or restructuring a function can be very different from operating within one that is already established.
The question isn’t whether they have worked at scale, but what they personally changed while operating at scale:
- Have they built capability as the business grew?
- Have they integrated teams or businesses?
- Have they simplified processes or structures?
- Have they introduced greater financial discipline or controls without creating unnecessary bureaucracy?
The scale of the organisation provides context. What they did within it tells you far more.
How should CFOs build a finance leadership team for the future?
By building the team backwards from the challenges ahead.
We’ve had a lot of success with CFOs by starting with what the business needs to achieve and working backwards to understand the leadership capability required to get there.
It sounds straightforward, but it can produce a very different brief from starting with an existing job description or looking for a like-for-like replacement.
01
Start with the business challenges, not the org chart.
What will finance genuinely need to solve over the next three to five years? Where will the greatest demands on the leadership team come from?
02
Translate business challenges into finance leadership capabilities.
Rather than “we need a Divisional CFO from our sector”, it might be “we need someone who has scaled a business, made difficult capital allocation decisions and successfully influenced operational leaders.”
That can lead you to people you might have ruled out based on sector, title or company background alone.
03
Assess where you have strength and where you have gaps.
Where do you already have strength? Where are the gaps? And which of those gaps could be addressed by giving existing leaders greater exposure or different experiences?
Look at what people have actually been responsible for: the decisions they’ve made, the problems they’ve solved, the change they’ve led and the situations where they’ve had to exercise judgement.
This is where succession planning becomes practical. For potential CFO successors and other senior finance leaders, it can highlight the experiences they still need to gain before they’re ready to step up.
For some organisations, a more structured leadership assessment can help build a clearer picture of the strengths across the finance team, identify development priorities and understand where additional capability may be needed.
Where do you already have strength? Where are the gaps? And which of those gaps could be addressed by giving existing leaders greater exposure or different experiences?
Look at what people have actually been responsible for: the decisions they’ve made, the problems they’ve solved, the change they’ve led and the situations where they’ve had to exercise judgement.
This is where succession planning becomes practical. For potential CFO successors and other senior finance leaders, it can highlight the experiences they still need to gain before they’re ready to step up.
For some organisations, a more structured leadership assessment can help build a clearer picture of the strengths across the finance team, identify development priorities and understand where additional capability may be needed.
04
Hire finance leaders for the capabilities you're missing.
Once you understand the strengths and gaps across the existing team, you can be much clearer about what you need to bring in.
A vacancy doesn’t necessarily need to be filled with a like-for-like replacement. It can be an opportunity to add experience the team doesn’t currently have, strengthen an area where future demands will be greater, or bring in someone who could form part of the longer-term succession plan.
Each appointment should leave the finance leadership team stronger than it was before.
This capability-led approach is central to how we approach CFO and senior finance executive search, helping us define what an organisation needs from its next finance leader before determining where that person might come from.
Is your finance leadership team ready for what the business needs next?
Understanding the capabilities already present in the team, where people need further experience and where bringing in someone new could add something different gives CFOs a much clearer basis for decisions about development, succession and external hiring.
The aim is to build a finance leadership team capable of taking greater ownership of these challenges, giving the CFO the support they need and ensuring the team is equipped for what the business will ask of it next.
FAQs
A high-performing finance leadership team needs commercial judgement, strong prioritisation, the ability to connect people, process and technology, and experience scaling organisations. Senior finance leaders should be able to make difficult investment trade-offs, turn technology investment into business value and take ownership of complex business challenges without relying on the CFO for every decision.
CFOs should assess leaders against the decisions they have made, problems they have solved and transformations they have led, not simply job titles, sectors or company size. Evidence of capital allocation, prioritisation, scaling and cross-functional leadership can provide a stronger indication of future performance than previous roles alone.
CFO succession planning should identify both potential successors and the experiences they still need before they are ready to step up. Assessing the finance team against future business challenges can reveal capability gaps, development opportunities and areas where external recruitment may strengthen the succession pipeline.
Finance leaders increasingly need to understand how AI and technology create business value rather than becoming technical experts themselves. They should be able to challenge investment assumptions, assess ROI, improve decision-making and connect technology implementation with changes to people, processes, data and operating models.

